Line up Tolland's single-family median sale price month by month and it looks unsettled. It was $480,000 in July 2026, $515,000 in August, $462,450 in September and $435,000 in October, according to SmartMLS. That is an $80,000 drop from the August peak to October. In October the same figure was also up 13.0% from October 2025, the kind of jump that ends up in a headline.
Neither the drop nor the jump says much about what a house in Tolland is worth. The number that held still this fall says more. At the end of October 2026, 36 single-family homes were for sale in Tolland, exactly as many as at the end of October 2025. Over the same year, inventory roughly doubled in Ellington and rose by a third in Vernon. If you're weighing Tolland against the towns around it this winter, that stability matters more than any monthly price.
A median is a count of what closed
A median sale price is the middle sale out of whatever closed that month. In a town of Tolland's size that's a small group. October 2026 had 13 single-family closings in Tolland. September had 18, August had 18 and July had 27. With 13 sales, the median is the seventh house. Swap a four-bedroom colonial for a smaller ranch in that month's mix and the "market" moves by tens of thousands of dollars, even though no house changed in value.
SmartMLS says so itself. A note on its October 2026 Tolland report warns that percent changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." October also shows how far apart two measures from the same 13 sales can sit. The month's median was $435,000 and its average was $461,831. Through October, the year-to-date average was $505,119. When an average runs above the median, a handful of higher-priced sales is pulling it up, and the median stays put.
The towns next door make the same point even more clearly. In Ellington, October 2026's median sale price fell 21.0% from a year earlier to $395,000. In the same month, from the same 12 closings, Ellington's average sale price rose 14.3% to $549,733. In Willington, October's median rose 124.3% to $785,000 on four sales. Willington's home values did not more than double in a year. Four closings just landed in a different part of the price range than they had the October before.
The year-to-date line moves slowly
Pool the months together and Tolland's price picture flattens out. Through October 2026, Tolland recorded 132 single-family closings, up 7.3% from the same period of 2025, at a year-to-date median of $458,500. That's 1.9% higher than the $450,000 year-to-date median through October 2025.
The year-to-date median itself drifted in a narrow band through the summer and fall. It was $445,250 through July, $469,500 through August, $470,000 through September and $458,500 through October 2026. Over four months the cumulative figure stayed within about $25,000. Over the same stretch, the monthly figure moved $80,000. If you want a price anchor for Tolland, the year-to-date line is the one to use, and it puts the first ten months of 2026 close to the same stretch of 2025.
The pace eased a little, and the pool stayed the same size
Prices that barely moved don't mean nothing changed. Year to date through October 2026, the median Tolland single-family home spent 21 days on the market before sale, up from 17 in the same period of 2025. Over the same stretch, sellers received 104.3% of list price, down from 105.5%. Both shifts point the same way. Tolland homes still sell above asking, but the premium is about a point smaller and buyers have had a few more days to decide than they did in 2025.
October alone moved the other way on speed. Homes that closed that month took 9 days, against 21 in October 2025, and still brought 103.1% of list. As with price, one month of 13 closings is a weaker read than the ten-month pattern.
Supply is the steadiest figure in the reports. Tolland had 36 single-family homes for sale at the end of October 2026, the same count as a year earlier, which works out to 2.7 months of supply, slightly below October 2025's 2.9. September's month-end count was 37 in both years. Through October, sellers put 181 new single-family listings on the market, up 1.1% from 179 in the same period of 2025. Sellers aren't holding back and they aren't rushing in. The flow of Tolland homes coming to market in 2026 nearly matches 2025.
Next door, the supply picture moved
Tolland's flat inventory stands out once you set it beside the neighboring towns. Here's how each town's October 2026 month-end supply compared with October 2025, with the year-to-date median for context, from SmartMLS Local Market Updates.
| Town | Homes for sale, Oct. 2025 | Homes for sale, Oct. 2026 | Months of supply, Oct. 2026 | YTD median through Oct. 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tolland | 36 | 36 | 2.7 | $458,500 |
| Ellington | 14 | 31 | 3.0 | $498,000 |
| Vernon | 25 | 33 | 2.1 | $388,965 |
| Coventry | 19 | 17 | 1.6 | $415,000 |
| Mansfield | 26 | 16 | 1.8 | $430,000 |
| Bolton | 11 | 15 | 3.2 | $450,000 |
Ellington had the biggest change. It went from 1.2 months of supply in October 2025 to 3.0 in October 2026, and its year-to-date new listings rose 20.0% to 150. For a buyer, that's the clearest sign of more choice of any town in this group. Vernon added inventory too, and its supply rose from 1.5 to 2.1 months. Vernon's year-to-date median rose 11.1% even so, and its sellers have received 106.1% of list price this year. Coventry and Mansfield went the other way. Each finished October 2026 with less than two months of supply.
Tolland's supply sits in the middle of this group. It isn't as tight as Coventry, it hasn't loosened the way Ellington has, and its year-to-date price gain of 1.9% is smaller than Vernon's, Coventry's or Ellington's. If you're comparing these towns, Tolland in 2026 looks a lot like Tolland in 2025: about the same number of homes to choose from, prices close to last year's, and offers that still usually come in above asking.
What's being planned in town is apartments and age-restricted housing
The new housing approved or under discussion in Tolland this year wouldn't change the detached single-family count the SmartMLS reports track. In August 2026, the Journal Inquirer, via CT Insider, reported that local officials approved Metro Realty Group's 71-unit apartment plan at 312 Merrow Road. The plan calls for 33 one-bedroom and 38 two-bedroom apartments in six two-story buildings, with a 17.9-acre conservation restriction on the wooded southeast part of the 30.9-acre lot. The site is between the Baxter Street and Goose Lane intersections, near an I-84 exit on the main route to UConn's Storrs campus.
At its November 4, 2026 meeting, the town's Economic Development Commission said it favors age-restricted housing at the Tolland Village site, including some senior affordable units, and planned to pass that preference along to interested developers. That's a stated preference, not an approved project. Neither plan adds homes to Tolland's single-family resale market. For buyers shopping that market, the steady flow of resale listings, 181 through October 2026, is still the supply to watch. If you're thinking about building instead, our earlier post on new construction in Tolland goes into that route.
One carrying cost also changed this year. Tolland's adopted mill rate for fiscal year 2026/27 is 27.78, up from 27.19 the year before, according to the town's tax calculation page. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own figures with the Tolland Assessor or a qualified professional.
Questions buyers comparing Tolland are asking
Did Tolland home prices go up 13% this year? The 13.0% figure compares October 2026's median with October 2025's, and it rests on 13 closings. Through October, the year-to-date median rose 1.9%, to $458,500.
Are Tolland homes still selling above asking? Year to date through October 2026, sellers received 104.3% of list price, a little below the 105.5% they got in the same period of 2025.
Which nearby town has the most homes to choose from right now? Among the towns compared here, Bolton had the most months of supply at the end of October 2026, at 3.2, but with only 15 homes for sale. Ellington had 31 homes for sale and 3.0 months of supply. Tolland's 36 homes made the largest inventory in the group, but at 2.7 months of supply it sells through faster.
When does the November picture come out? SmartMLS posts town-level Local Market Updates monthly, and the October 2026 reports were current as of November 8. You'll find Tolland's on the SmartMLS market statistics site.
If you own a home in Tolland and want to know what it would bring in this market, without leaning on one month's median, The Corrado Group can walk you through the Tolland sales that matter for your house. Request a complimentary home valuation to get started.